Imperial College London (2021) metaphy.org
Should I disbelieve in quantum mechanics
because Einstein never accepted it? Unlike religion, physics does not accept the word of gurus, based on faith, even if the name of the guru is Einstein, and he is one of the greatest physicists who ever lived. No physicist assumes that even Einstein is correct on all matters. He is not accepted on authority; he is accepted by the arguments and deductions that he made that can be checked theoretically and tested experimentally. We don’t care what Einstein believed, but we do care about what he demonstrated and derived. Einstein himself always emphasized that his theories needed to be tested experimentally, and if they failed, then he himself would reject them.physicists believe
Einstein’s disbelief in free will depended on large part on a statement made in 1839 by Schopenhauer. Schopenhauer addressed his argument not to a meeting of philosophers, but to the Royal Norwegian Society of Sciences. His paper was titled “On the Freedom of Will”. He argued that humans do not possess anything but the illusion of free will. He said, “You can do what you will, but in any given moment of your life you can will only one definite thing and absolutely nothing other than that one thing.”
But Schopenhauer’s logic
was based on the assumption that physics was complete, that is, given perfect knowledge of the past, we could predict the future with utter certainty. That left no room for free will. Einstein knew that quantum mechanics implied that physics was not complete. Einstein was distressed
by this feature of quantum physics, and was (from what I have read) his fundamental basis for rejecting the quantum theory.
Thanks to the measurements of radioactive decay and quantum entanglement, we now have compelling evidence that physics is incomplete, and that negates the logical basis for Schopenhauer’s argument. Thus Einstein’s conclusion was based on a false premise.
That doesn’t mean that Einstein is wrong. I can’t use physics to demonstrate that free will exists
. I can simply say that the argument used to deny free will
was incorrect.
I discuss all these issues (including the role of radioactive decay and entanglement, and the logic of Schopenhauer and Einstein) at some length in my new book Now: The Physics of Time
.
No comments:
Post a Comment